Comments from Fritz Steiner

1)

a)

The application permits letters of support. I'll try to get a
commitment from Jack Dangerman.
 

b)  Edits:


Under
Problem, I think we're interested in both the "drivers of" as well as the controls on change. Under tools, I think we're
interested in urban and ecological modeling. Both are more complex than land-use modeling. I think we ought to involve a modeler
and would suggest my colleague Subhrajit Guhathakurta. He organized the symposium last weekend. Another application of IT (in
addition to data fusion etc. is  the  analysis and the synthesis of information. In the first line of the Introduction, I'd
suggest "... region comprises a desert landscape transforming through a suburban matrix to an urban center. ..."

On the second
page, I really love the sentence "To anticipate the future, ..."

The sentence about this year's ballot begs for more elaboration.
I'd suggest something like: Growth management is a much debated issue in the region. It has been the subject of legislative
action, blue ribbon panels, and ballot-box initiatives. What has been missing is in-depth scientific analysis of the consequences
of the various growth management options."

The "Changing how atlases are constructed " is neat.

Let's add post-docs to those
compiling the data. The RFP emphasizes post-docs over staff.
 

2)


For real IT types he [Fink] suggested UC San Barbara and/or Los Alamos.
I've got a good contact at UCSB, Mike Goodchild, and will contact him. Jon will put us in touch with the national lab folks.
 

Here is email from Goodchild:

From: Mike Goodchild [mailto:good@geog.ucsb.edu]
Sent: Tuesday, October 24, 2000 1:47 PM
To: Frederick Steiner
Subject: Re: FW: Greater Phoenix 2100: IT proposal development

Possibly, but it would have to be in a peripheral role given the Phoenix emphasis - and I'm going to have to put a lot of effort into a proposal from here (very different topic!) -
thanks for thinking of me

I also suggested Ray Quay, the assistant Phoenix planning director who is also a computer geek and an adjunct professor in our
school. He writes software. The NSF RFP emphasizes connections with governments. Involving Ray would help.

Here is email from Ray Quay:

    I would be interested in being part of the discussion as you refine
     your focus.  I looked over the materials, and what you are discussing
     is certainly of interest to me and relates to some of my past work.
     At this point I am unsure what role I could play though I could likely
     provide comments about practical application or big picture issues.
 
     Finding ITM people is not hard if you have sufficient money to attract
     and keep them.  The hard part will be someone who can translate thier
     language into the language of the problem set at hand.
 
     Ray
 

Did you forward to
Suzanne? Jon said she is a terrific editor. She can help with the budget too.

Jon said it would be good politics for us to add
match. He offered an "environmentally sensitive IT type. " Such a match would help us run the project and not run into NSF's
staff land mine. We could shift the requested funds from a staff position to post doc support.
 

3)

page 3, Anglo is an offensive (to me) regionally vernacular.
There's a great number of so-called white Americans who aren't Anglos, fled from the Anglos, and/or can't stand the Anglos. In my
view, the term Anglo privileges a minority. Although it has baggage too, why not "American" exploration? It's more accurate.

I
know what you mean by "freely accessible" but it could be read that we'll be giving the atlas away which may not be the case. How
about "easily accessible" instead?

On page 4, additional multidisciplinary strengths include our GIS certificate and the
EPA-funded SCERP project. We're also engaged in a "virtual studio" with three Italian universities on the planning of Sardinia.
We could involve them as collaborators. NSF encourages international cooperation but won't fund it.

On page 5, instead of
"voters" I'd recommend "citizens."

Here we should reduce that staff request add post docs and add Jon's staff environmentally
friendly IT type.
 

4)

It occurred to me that
it would be important to involve a graphic designer in the project. Many of them are quite good with web design and obviously
expert in visual communication. I'd recommend Melissa Niederhelman of our graphic design program. I've worked with her and she's
terrific plus her research is related to interactive communications.